Templars, Hospitallers, Teutonic Knights and Crusaders: Key Differences

Templars, Hospitallers, Teutonic Knights and Crusaders: Key Differences

Table of Contents

Short answer: the Knights Templar, the Knights Hospitaller, and the Teutonic Knights were military orders: communities of knights who took lifelong religious vows and lived like monks while fighting. Ordinary crusaders were different: they took a vow for one campaign and then usually went home. The Templars were founded around 1119 to 1120 to protect pilgrims and were dissolved in 1312. The Hospitallers grew out of a hospital in Jerusalem and still exist today as the Order of Malta. The Teutonic Knights began at the siege of Acre in 1190, fought mainly in the Baltic, and still exist as a Catholic religious order.

Military Orders vs Crusaders

A crusader knight made a personal vow to join a crusade. When the campaign was over, his vow was fulfilled. A knight of a military order made permanent religious vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience, lived under a rule, prayed daily with his brothers, and served the order for life. Read Crusader Knights: History, Armor, and Role in the Crusades for more on the crusaders themselves.

The orders gave the crusader states something the crusades could not: a permanent, disciplined force that held castles and escorted pilgrims year after year.

The Orders at a Glance

Knights Templar Knights Hospitaller Teutonic Knights
Origin Jerusalem, around 1119 to 1120 Hospital in Jerusalem, 11th century; recognized as an order in 1113 Field hospital at the siege of Acre, 1190; military order from 1198
Main purpose Protect pilgrims, defend the crusader states Care for the sick and pilgrims, later military defense Care for German crusaders, later crusades in the Baltic
Main areas Holy Land, estates across Europe Holy Land, then Cyprus, Rhodes, and Malta Holy Land, then Prussia and the Baltic
Habit White mantle, with a red cross from about 1147 Black mantle with a white cross; in battle, a red surcoat with a white cross from the 13th century White mantle with a black cross
Known for Heavy cavalry, castles, a financial network Hospitals, great castles, later naval warfare Castles and a monastic state in Prussia
Fate Arrested in 1307, dissolved in 1312 Still exists as the Sovereign Military Order of Malta Still exists as a Catholic religious order

The Knights Templar

The Templars were founded around 1119 to 1120 in Jerusalem by a small group of knights led by Hugues de Payens, to protect pilgrims on the roads of the Holy Land. They took their name from their headquarters on the Temple Mount. In 1129, the Council of Troyes gave them an official rule, and papal privileges soon followed.

The order grew fast. Templar knights became an elite heavy cavalry known for their discipline, and the order held castles across the crusader states. Gifts of land and money made them rich, and their houses across Europe developed a network for storing and moving funds that worked much like early banking.

After the fall of Acre in 1291, the crusader states were lost, and the Templars lost their main purpose. In 1307, King Philip IV of France had the Templars in France arrested on charges of heresy and other crimes. Under pressure, Pope Clement V dissolved the order in 1312. The last Grand Master, Jacques de Molay, was burned in Paris in 1314, and much Templar property was transferred to the Hospitallers.

The Knights Hospitaller

The Hospitallers, or Order of Saint John, began with a hospital for pilgrims in Jerusalem in the 11th century. In 1113, the pope recognized it as an independent religious order. Over the 12th century, especially from the 1130s, the brothers took on more and more military duties, while still running hospitals. Their castles included Krak des Chevaliers in Syria.

After the fall of Acre in 1291, the Hospitallers moved to Cyprus, and in 1310 they took Rhodes, where they became a naval power. When the Ottomans captured Rhodes in 1522, the order moved to Malta in 1530 and ruled the island until Napoleon took it in 1798. Today, the Sovereign Military Order of Malta is a Catholic humanitarian organization.

The Teutonic Knights

The Teutonic Order began as a field hospital set up by German crusaders during the siege of Acre in 1190 and became a military order in 1198. Its knights wore a white mantle with a black cross.

From the 13th century, the order turned its main effort to the Baltic, where it led crusades against pagan peoples and built a state of its own in Prussia, with great brick castles such as Marienburg. In 1410, the Teutonic Knights suffered a heavy defeat at the Battle of Grunwald (Tannenberg) against Poland and Lithuania. The order survived, but its power declined. In 1525, its last Grand Master in Prussia turned the order's Prussian lands into a secular duchy. The order lives on today as a Catholic religious order focused on pastoral and charitable work.

Crusaders Outside the Orders

Most knights on crusade did not belong to any order. They were nobles and their followers who took the cross for one expedition, wore their own heraldry with a cross sewn on their clothes, and fought under their own lords. They formed the bulk of crusading armies, in campaigns such as the siege of Antioch, the capture of Jerusalem in 1099, and the Battle of Arsuf in 1191. Many went home when their vow was fulfilled, and some settled in the crusader states. For their history, armor, and weapons, read our guide to crusader knights.

How to Portray a Knightly Order in LARP

  • Use the colors. A white tabard with a red cross, a black tabard with a white cross (or a red one with a white cross for a Hospitaller in battle), or a white tabard with a black cross makes each order instantly readable.
  • Show the discipline. Members of an order act as a unit: shared prayers, strict hierarchy, plain dress, and loyalty to the order before personal glory.
  • Choose the era. Mail, a surcoat, and a great helm fit the 12th and 13th centuries. Later Teutonic or Hospitaller knights can wear more plate.
  • Create your own order for fantasy games. Many fantasy LARPs work best with an invented holy order inspired by history: your own colors, symbol, and oath. It avoids clashing with the setting and gives your group a unique identity.

For holy warriors and knightly orders, see our Paladin and Knight armor collections. If your whole group wants matching armor in its own colors, see our group orders.

Frequently Asked Questions

What Is the Difference Between Templars and Crusaders?

Templars were members of a military order who lived under a religious rule for life. Ordinary crusaders took a vow for a single campaign, wore their own heraldry with a cross, and fought under their own lords.

What Is the Difference Between Templars, Hospitallers, and Teutonic Knights?

All three were military orders. The Templars protected pilgrims and were dissolved in 1312. The Hospitallers began as a hospital and later ruled Rhodes and Malta. The Teutonic Knights began at Acre in 1190 and later fought and ruled in the Baltic.

What Happened to the Knights Templar?

After the crusader states were lost in 1291, King Philip IV of France had the Templars in France arrested in 1307. Pope Clement V dissolved the order in 1312, and much of its property was transferred to the Hospitallers.

Do the Hospitallers Still Exist?

Yes. After Rhodes and Malta, the order continued and exists today as the Sovereign Military Order of Malta, a Catholic humanitarian organization.

Do the Teutonic Knights Still Exist?

Yes. The order lost most of its power after the 15th and 16th centuries, but it still exists today as a Catholic religious order focused on pastoral and charitable work.

What Colors Did the Military Orders Wear?

The Templars wore a white mantle, with a red cross from about 1147. The Hospitallers wore a black mantle with a white cross, and in battle a red surcoat with a white cross. The Teutonic Knights wore a white mantle with a black cross.

Recommended Armor

Flower Knight Greaves

Flower Knight Greaves

Flower Knight Greaves

$175.50 $195.00

ITEM INFORMATION Category: LARP Leg Armor. Style: High Medieval Fantasy, Floral Fantasy Armor, Ornate Knight Armor, Romantic Fantasy. Product Includes: Pair of greaves with padding. Base Colors: Da...

Empire Armor Breastplate

Empire Armor Breastplate

Empire Armor Breastplate

$171.00 $190.00
(2)

ITEM INFORMATION Category: LARP Body Armor. Style: Dark Fantasy, Imperial Heraldic, Gothic Knightly Armor. Product Includes: One breastplate. Base Colors: Black, Antique Gold. The Empire Armor Brea...

Lion Knight Tassets

Lion Knight Tassets

Lion Knight Tassets

$139.50 $155.00

ITEM INFORMATION Category: LARP Hip Armor. Style: High Medieval Fantasy, Lion Knight Armor, Noble Knight Armor, Heraldic Armor. Product Includes: Pair of tassets. Base Colors: Dark Metal, Bronze. T...

See all Knight LARP Armor
Share this article: